The Silent Majority Has Become a Voting Majority. What’s Next for the Czech Bar Association?

When news broke on Tuesday morning that a nighttime power outage had interrupted the Czech Bar Association’s vote, I thought I would be writing about how the Association has to deal with a new norm: Murphy’s Law. Little did I know that the silent majority of lawyers had turned into a voting majority, making the brief inability to cast a ballot completely irrelevant in the grand scheme of things. In the per rollam (remote) vote, lawyers decisively—by roughly 85 to 15—rejected an increase in membership fees for the Czech Bar Association, as well as a proposal to raise the number of lawyers required to trigger such a vote. How should we read these results, and what are the takeaways? Here are my personal observations.

Jan Januš
Zdroj: archiv Jana Januše

First, the majority of lawyers are, after all, willing to participate in the governance of their profession to some extent when something truly matters to them. Practically since the founding of the Czech Bar Association, it had seemed that this was not the case.

Second, I do not think the majority of voters genuinely minded that fees would increase after so many years. Rather, that majority concluded that the Association manages a large enough budget and sufficient reserves to find the necessary funds internally.

Third, even though the majority of the Board of Directors presented the matter as having no alternative, they failed to convince the majority of the profession they represent. While the Czech Bar Association has recently been trying to communicate more actively and transparently, most lawyers still do not consider it sufficient and clearly need even more information.

Fourth, at the same time, it is not the case that the current leadership of the Czech Bar Association has lost the trust of lawyers altogether. Aside from isolated voices, I have not noticed anyone calling for new elections, nor has there been any significant pressure for anyone in the Association’s leadership to step down.

Fifth, the decisive outcome of the vote—even though it went against what the majority of the Board advocated—is good news for the Czech legal profession and the Czech rule of law. Nobody is questioning the legitimacy of the vote, even though during the process it looked as if we were headed in that exact direction. Hopefully, this will also put an end to biased articles, as well as personal attacks and defamation involving, for example, AI-generated images. Czech law and society truly do not need this, especially in today’s climate.

The Czech Bar Association now has a historic opportunity: perhaps for the first time in its history, the Board of Directors has gained an exact reading of the mood among the majority of lawyers. And it can act accordingly.


Translated from Czech using artificial intelligence.